For businesses that handle a fleet, the decision to lease or buy vehicles is an important financial one. Mahony Fleet has over 55 years of experience assisting Irish businesses in making these selections and delivering personalised leasing solutions suitable for small-to-medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) and multinational corporations. This article will explore the financial effects of leasing and buying to give business owners and fleet managers the information they need to decide which option may be most appropriate for their business requirements.

Overview Of Fleet Financing Options

Financing a fleet is not a one-size-fits-all solution. Businesses must think about various financing choices, considering their operation requirements, financial status, and strategic plans over the long run. Knowing these can aid businesses in improving their fleet activities while keeping their financial flexibility and stability intact.

Leasing is often chosen by businesses that want a new fleet but are not tied to the whole expense of owning it. With this option, a company can use a vehicle for an agreed period and make monthly payments. There are various kinds of leasing plans, including the following:

  • Operating Leases: This kind of lease is usual, where the person who rents (lessee) pays for using the vehicle but gives it back when the lease term finishes. It helps to avoid the risk of value loss. It’s perfect for companies that wish to constantly renew their fleet of vehicles without dealing with selling old ones.
  • Finance Leases: This arrangement gives the business an option to use the vehicle for a longer time. The lease is created so that the company can buy it at the end of the agreement period with residual value. This option is good for businesses that may want to own a vehicle later on but like spreading their payments.
  • Contract Hire: It’s an arrangement similar to operational leasing, but the deal incorporates lease payments and maintenance and servicing costs here. This is especially advantageous for organisations desiring a sole regular monthly payment, which includes the majority of vehicle-related expenses.

The lease gives big benefits, like less money to spend at the start, possible tax advantages (usually, lease payments can be removed as business costs), and the freedom to frequently change your fleet. But, you need to know that leasing doesn’t allow unlimited mileage or any modifications without cost.

Purchasing Outright

Acquiring a vehicle outright entails purchasing it with a single payment or using a loan. This selection allows the business to have total ownership of the car and use it according to their requirements without limitations set by leasing conditions.

  • Advantages: The primary benefit is the nonexistence of contractual constraints. The business can utilise the vehicle in any manner and for any period. Having a car means no monthly lease payments, which could be more economical over an extended period for cars that are used for many years.
  • Disadvantages: The initial financial expenditure is big, and the business takes on all expenses connected to the vehicle, such as the loss in value of the vehicle over time (depreciation), looking after it (maintenance), and fixing things that go wrong with it (repairs). This also means that the business takes on any remaining value risk from the vehicle.

PCP Financing (Personal Contract Purchase)

A person is finalizing a car lease agreement.

Even though Personal Contract Purchase (PCP) is a method of financing that is mainly used for personal vehicles, it is becoming more popular in commercial fleet use as well. This option allows for smaller monthly payments and a larger final payment if the business chooses to buy the vehicle at the end of the contract.

How It Works: PCP financing requires the business to pay a deposit, and then they make lower monthly payments. These payments are for the decrease in the value of the vehicle and not its total worth. When agreement ends, there is the option for business to pay the last balloon payment (also called Guaranteed Minimum Future Value or GMFV) so that it can own this vehicle completely, trade in the vehicle for a new one, or return back their car without any more duties and responsibilities (except for certain rules related with mileage and condition).

  • Benefits: PCP benefits companies who want flexibility once the agreement concludes, along with reduced monthly payments throughout the contract duration. It additionally offers opportunities to frequently update cars without encountering difficulties in selling previous models.
  • Disadvantages: If the business chooses to purchase the vehicle after the term ends, it may face a higher total cost compared to other financing methods because of this balloon payment. In addition, mileage limits and possible charges for excessive wear can apply, just like in leasing situations.

Evaluating the Options

Every method of financing has its own financial consequences, advantages, and disadvantages. Businesses must consider these factors when assessing the different options:

  • Cash Flow: How will the financing option impact your monthly and annual cash flow?
  • Vehicle Turnover: How frequently does the business need or want to update its fleet?
  • Tax Implications: What are each option’s potential tax benefits or liabilities?
  • Usage Patterns: Consider the vehicle’s mileage and type of use, as this can greatly affect which financing options are more cost-effective.
  • Risk of Future Value: What is the significance of residual value risk regarding the business’s overall financial strategy?

Businesses must consider all these factors carefully to know which funding option is most suitable for their fleet. This choice will depend on the type and size of vehicles, how long they are used, and specific financial requirements such as balance sheet impact and tax implications. By comprehensively evaluating these elements, businesses can make choices that fit their operation needs and financial goals. If you are thinking about the best way to finance your fleet, contact Mahony Fleet today. We have experts who can help guide you in making this decision so that it aligns well with your operational efficiency and financial health.

Leasing Financial Implications

For businesses, understanding the financial intricacies of leasing is essential. They must understand the complex advantages of leasing, such as aiding in budget control, supporting strategic financial planning, and managing assets effectively. Let’s take a closer look at what leasing implies:

Lower Monthly Payments

The smaller monthly payments are an attractive part of leasing. When you lease a vehicle, your payment only covers the decrease in value during that lease period; it does not include the total buying cost. The result can be a noticeable drop in each month’s cash outflow—this makes it simpler for businesses to handle their financial matters and set aside funds for other crucial growth zones.

  • Budgeting that can be Predicted: Businesses can predict and plan their budgets better because the monthly payments are stable and lower. There aren’t any unexpected changes, and fixed expenses support steady cash inflow.
  • Increased liquidity: When the monthly payments are reduced, less money is blocked in vehicles. This leads to improved liquidity, allowing businesses to invest in other areas with better returns on investment.

Tax Benefits

Another financial advantage of leasing is the opportunity to receive tax benefits. Lease payments are often seen as a kind of business expense that can be deducted, which may lower the company’s total tax responsibility.

  • Operating Lease Deductions: The entire lease payment can be considered a business expense for many businesses, reducing taxable income and better financial statement results.
  • Benefits: Depending on the location and lease agreement details, businesses might be able to recover VAT on lease payments, which can decrease costs even more.

No Large Initial Capital Outlay

Leasing is very attractive because it doesn’t require a big upfront payment like buying a vehicle does. This can be quite helpful for small and medium-sized businesses, or SMEs, who might not have much money saved up for large expenses. Some of the other benefits include:

  • Cash Flow Management: Leasing allows businesses to avoid a large initial outlay, which helps manage their cash flow. This benefits expanding companies that want to keep their operations running smoothly while managing their cash flow.
  • Access to Higher Spec Vehicles: Businesses can access better and more expensive vehicles, which might not be possible if they had to pay a large initial payment.

Maintenance and Repair Costs

Some additional benefits of leasing include:

  • Maintenance costs are often covered: Some leases include a comprehensive maintenance package, which means the price for regular services and even certain common repairs is taken care of. This stabilises these expenses for business owners and fleet managers.
  • No Depreciation Risk: The leasing company owns the vehicle, so any decrease in value is their responsibility. This means businesses can utilise these vehicles without concern about losing their worth as time goes on.

Enhancing Business Credit

In addition, leasing can positively contribute to a business’s credit profile. Frequent and timely lease payments are usually registered with credit agencies, aiding in gradually establishing or enhancing a business’s creditworthiness over time.

Better credit ratings can boost a company’s capacity to borrow in the future, frequently at more favourable rates. This is key for sustained financial expansion and steadiness over time.

Fleet Management Efficiency

Many leasing firms propose comprehensive fleet management solutions encompassing administrative help, fuel management projects, and telematics services. This can help businesses focus on their primary operations more efficiently.

Residual Value Management

In leasing, the business does not bear responsibility for the residual value of the vehicle. At the end of the lease term, the vehicle is given back to the lessor, and thus, the risk related to reducing resale worth is minimised.

Asset management also helps businesses avoid the problems of asset decline and the risk of their fleet becoming outdated. It lets them keep a group of new, effective, and easy-to-handle operational needs vehicles without needing to sell off old ones.

All these elements make leasing a very appealing choice for many businesses. It reduces financial risk, provides a clear expense plan, and provides the adaptability required for efficient adjustment and growth of operations.

Comparing the Cost of Ownership Over Time

What is the Cost of Ownership? The cost of ownership means more than just the price you pay when you buy a vehicle. When looking at leasing or owning, think about these costs over the long haul:

  • Depreciation: Normally, the value of a vehicle goes down as it gets older. Those who lease don’t have to absorb this cost because they can return the car when their lease period finishes.
  • Maintenance and Repairs: Over time, vehicles need more upkeep, which adds to the cost of ownership. Maintenance fees are paid fully by the vehicle’s owner; however, lease agreements typically include these expenses in their terms.
  • Opportunity Cost: The money used to buy a vehicle could be used for other business investments. Leasing allows you to save this capital.

Knowing these continuing expenses can help businesses make better choices about which financing option will result in lower costs over time.

Flexibility and Financial Risks With Leasing vs Owning

The decision between leasing and owning is influenced by the flexibility of each choice and the financial exposures:

  • Flexibility: Leasing allows for more flexibility in moving to newer models or modifying the fleet size per business requirements without needing to sell off older vehicles.
  • Financial Risks: People who own vehicles take on the risk of their resale value changing, but those who lease are protected from this risk. Nevertheless, those renting a car should consider the miles they are allowed to drive and the possible costs for extreme use or damage to it.

These considerations are significant for businesses that are keen on having contemporary fleets without the fiscal instability of vehicle ownership.

Case Studies and Real-Life SME Examples

To illustrate the benefits of leasing, consider these SME examples:

  • Tech Startup: A tech startup from Dublin required a group of cars for its sales team. By leasing, it could provide top-tier vehicles with up-to-date technology without wasting money that might be utilised in research and development.
  • Construction Company: A small construction business found renting heavy vehicles and equipment beneficial, as they were not affordable for direct purchase. This helped enhance their cash flow and lessen maintenance concerns.

These examples show how different types of businesses can leverage leasing to their advantage.

Fleet Financing Considerations

When evaluating financing considerations for your fleet, take into account:

  • Credit Rating: If your business has a good credit rating, it may get better leasing conditions.
  • Mileage Requirements: High-mileage businesses might find leases less attractive due to mileage caps.
  • Vehicle Customization: Purchasing may be necessary if specific customizations are required for the business.

This understanding will guide you in selecting the financing option that best suits your business’s operations and financial plans.

When businesses consider leasing vs. purchasing, they consider the positive financial effects now versus future expenses and flexibility. Leasing can offer additional advantages like less money needed, tax benefits, and freeing up capital. On the other hand, buying might be better for businesses that use vehicles or need to customise them.

For the finest fleet financing plan for your business, contact Mahony Fleet. Our expertise in this area can direct you throughout the procedure, ensuring you select the choice that gives maximum financial and operation benefits. Allow us to assist you in enhancing your fleet investment with an appropriate finance solution.


Contact our Sales Team today